Baseball GOATLoading rankings
Loading rankings
Ranked by career score. That covers a player’s whole career, not only his time with this team. Players need at least 3 seasons there to make the list.
Cy Young
starting pitcher, 1890–1911
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1909–1911, 63 games
Compare with Speaker117.9
No. 3 all-time
Tris Speaker
center field, 1907–1928
11 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1916–1926, 1,521 games
Compare with Young95.8
No. 10 all-time
Frank Robinson
right field, 1956–1976
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1974–1976, 100 games
Compare with Young74.5
No. 33 all-time
Nap Lajoie
second base, 1896–1916
13 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1902–1914, 1,614 games
Compare with Young74.3
No. 35 all-time
Bert Blyleven
starting pitcher, 1970–1992
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1981–1985, 104 games
Compare with Young68.4
No. 45 all-time
Gaylord Perry
starting pitcher, 1962–1983
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1972–1975, 134 games
Compare with Young68.2
No. 47 all-time
Bob Feller
starting pitcher, 1936–1956
18 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1936–1956, 570 games
Compare with Young64.1
No. 65 all-time
Manny Ramirez
left field, 1993–2011
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1993–2000, 967 games
Compare with Young61.3
No. 76 all-time
Jim Thome
first base, 1991–2012
13 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1991–2011, 1,399 games
Compare with Young58.4
No. 98 all-time
Stan Coveleski
starting pitcher, 1912–1928
9 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1916–1924, 361 games
Compare with Young57.3
No. 110 all-time
Wes Ferrell
starting pitcher, 1927–1941
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1927–1933, 267 games
Compare with Young55.5
No. 127 all-time
Shoeless Joe Jackson
right field, 1908–1920
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1910–1915, 674 games
Compare with Young55.2
No. 131 all-time
Early Wynn
starting pitcher, 1939–1963
10 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1949–1963, 368 games
Compare with Young54.8
No. 132 all-time
Luis Tiant
starting pitcher, 1964–1982
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1964–1969, 211 games
Compare with Young53.4
No. 146 all-time
Bob Lemon
starting pitcher, 1941–1958
15 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1941–1958, 615 games
Compare with Young52.4
No. 159 all-time
Roberto Alomar
second base, 1988–2004
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1999–2001, 471 games
Compare with Young52.3
No. 161 all-time
Larry Doby
center field, 1942–1959
10 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1947–1958, 1,235 games
Compare with Young51.3
No. 170 all-time
CC Sabathia
starting pitcher, 2001–2019
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2001–2008, 238 games
Compare with Young49.2
No. 191 all-time
Addie Joss
starting pitcher, 1902–1910
9 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1902–1910, 296 games
Compare with Young48.6
No. 205 all-time
Brian Giles
right field, 1995–2009
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1995–1998, 299 games
Compare with Young48.3
No. 209 all-time
Earl Averill
center field, 1929–1941
11 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1929–1939, 1,510 games
Compare with Young48.1
No. 216 all-time
Dennis Eckersley
starting pitcher, 1975–1998
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1975–1977, 104 games
Compare with Young48.1
No. 219 all-time
Eddie Murray
first base, 1977–1997
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1994–1996, 309 games
Compare with Young46.9
No. 240 all-time
George Uhle
starting pitcher, 1919–1936
11 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1919–1936, 502 games
Compare with Young46.6
No. 244 all-time
Elmer Flick
right field, 1898–1910
9 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1902–1910, 936 games
Compare with Young46.4
No. 247 all-time
Toby Harrah
third base, 1969–1986
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1979–1983, 712 games
Compare with Young45.4
No. 278 all-time
Minnie Miñoso
left field, 1946–1980
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1949–1959, 314 games
Compare with Young45.1
No. 288 all-time
Jose Ramirez
third base, 2013–2025
13 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2013–2025, 1,609 games
Compare with Young45.1
No. 285 all-time
Albert Belle
left field, 1989–2000
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1989–1996, 913 games
Compare with Young44.7
No. 294 all-time
Lou Boudreau
shortstop, 1938–1952
13 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1938–1950, 1,560 games
Compare with Young44.2
No. 311 all-time
Mel Harder
starting pitcher, 1928–1947
20 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1928–1947, 584 games
Compare with Young43.6
No. 323 all-time
Brett Butler
center field, 1981–1997
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1984–1987, 609 games
Compare with Young43.4
No. 328 all-time
Orel Hershiser
starting pitcher, 1983–2000
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1995–1997, 91 games
Compare with Young43.4
No. 327 all-time
Francisco Lindor
shortstop, 2015–2025
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2015–2020, 777 games
Compare with Young42.8
No. 339 all-time
Dennis Martinez
starting pitcher, 1976–1998
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1994–1996, 72 games
Compare with Young42.7
No. 344 all-time
Chuck Finley
starting pitcher, 1986–2002
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2000–2002, 74 games
Compare with Young42.5
No. 350 all-time
Rocky Colavito
right field, 1955–1968
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1955–1967, 913 games
Compare with Young40.4
No. 390 all-time
Jim Perry
starting pitcher, 1959–1975
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1959–1975, 205 games
Compare with Young40.3
No. 393 all-time
Kenny Lofton
center field, 1991–2007
10 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1992–2007, 1,276 games
Compare with Young40.2
No. 399 all-time
Joe Sewell
shortstop, 1920–1933
11 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1920–1930, 1,513 games
Compare with Young39.7
No. 410 all-time
Ellis Burks
center field, 1987–2004
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2001–2003, 317 games
Compare with Young39.5
No. 418 all-time
Smoky Joe Wood
starting pitcher, 1908–1922
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1917–1922, 471 games
Compare with Young39.1
No. 434 all-time
Graig Nettles
third base, 1967–1988
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1970–1972, 465 games
Compare with Young38.5
No. 452 all-time
Julio Franco
second base, 1982–2007
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1983–1997, 1,088 games
Compare with Young38.3
No. 462 all-time
Thornton Lee
starting pitcher, 1933–1948
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1933–1936, 102 games
Compare with Young38.2
No. 466 all-time
Bartolo Colon
starting pitcher, 1997–2018
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1997–2002, 162 games
Compare with Young37.8
No. 476 all-time
Cliff Lee
starting pitcher, 2002–2014
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2002–2009, 182 games
Compare with Young37.5
No. 485 all-time
Sam McDowell
starting pitcher, 1961–1975
11 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1961–1971, 340 games
Compare with Young36.5
No. 514 all-time
Buddy Bell
third base, 1972–1989
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1972–1978, 987 games
Compare with Young36.2
No. 531 all-time
Joe Gordon
second base, 1938–1950
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1947–1950, 566 games
Compare with Young36.2
No. 529 all-time
Mike Garcia
starting pitcher, 1948–1961
12 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1948–1959, 397 games
Compare with Young36.0
No. 535 all-time
Al Rosen
third base, 1947–1956
10 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1947–1956, 1,044 games
Compare with Young35.6
No. 557 all-time
Victor Martinez
catcher, 2002–2018
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2002–2009, 821 games
Compare with Young35.1
No. 567 all-time
Jeff Heath
left field, 1936–1949
10 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1936–1945, 957 games
Compare with Young34.4
No. 592 all-time
Shin-Soo Choo
right field, 2005–2020
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2006–2012, 685 games
Compare with Young34.0
No. 607 all-time
Jim Bagby
starting pitcher, 1912–1923
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1916–1922, 299 games
Compare with Young33.8
No. 618 all-time
Jay Bell
shortstop, 1986–2003
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1986–1988, 116 games
Compare with Young33.5
No. 629 all-time
Earl Moore
starting pitcher, 1901–1914
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1901–1907, 161 games
Compare with Young33.5
No. 630 all-time
Ray Caldwell
starting pitcher, 1910–1921
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1919–1921, 87 games
Compare with Young33.3
No. 636 all-time
Allie Reynolds
starting pitcher, 1942–1954
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1942–1946, 161 games
Compare with Young32.7
No. 660 all-time
Roy Cullenbine
right field, 1938–1947
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1943–1945, 300 games
Compare with Young31.7
No. 700 all-time
Corey Kluber
starting pitcher, 2011–2023
9 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2011–2019, 210 games
Compare with Young31.4
No. 726 all-time
Tom Candiotti
starting pitcher, 1983–1999
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1986–1999, 184 games
Compare with Young30.9
No. 745 all-time
Rico Carty
left field, 1963–1979
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1974–1977, 430 games
Compare with Young30.8
No. 753 all-time
George Hendrick
center field, 1971–1988
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1973–1976, 546 games
Compare with Young30.7
No. 756 all-time
David Justice
right field, 1989–2002
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1997–2000, 486 games
Compare with Young30.4
No. 767 all-time
Larry Gardner
third base, 1908–1924
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1919–1924, 673 games
Compare with Young30.3
No. 770 all-time
Riggs Stephenson
left field, 1921–1934
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1921–1925, 331 games
Compare with Young29.8
No. 798 all-time
Gene Woodling
left field, 1943–1962
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1943–1957, 381 games
Compare with Young29.8
No. 797 all-time
Willis Hudlin
starting pitcher, 1926–1944
15 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1926–1940, 476 games
Compare with Young29.7
No. 808 all-time
Mickey Vernon
first base, 1939–1960
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1949–1958, 300 games
Compare with Young29.5
No. 819 all-time
Dick Donovan
starting pitcher, 1950–1965
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1962–1965, 108 games
Compare with Young29.2
No. 834 all-time
Carlos Santana
first base, 2010–2025
11 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2010–2025, 1,450 games
Compare with Young29.2
No. 832 all-time
Asdrubal Cabrera
shortstop, 2007–2021
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2007–2014, 914 games
Compare with Young29.1
No. 835 all-time
Johnny Allen
starting pitcher, 1932–1944
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1936–1940, 157 games
Compare with Young28.8
No. 857 all-time
Jhonny Peralta
shortstop, 2003–2017
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2003–2010, 923 games
Compare with Young28.5
No. 866 all-time
Sonny Siebert
starting pitcher, 1964–1975
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1964–1969, 185 games
Compare with Young28.5
No. 869 all-time
Steve Gromek
starting pitcher, 1941–1957
13 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1941–1953, 332 games
Compare with Young28.4
No. 881 all-time
Ken Keltner
third base, 1937–1950
12 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1937–1949, 1,513 games
Compare with Young28.4
No. 873 all-time
Rick Sutcliffe
starting pitcher, 1976–1994
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1982–1984, 85 games
Compare with Young28.2
No. 897 all-time
Vic Wertz
right field, 1947–1963
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1954–1958, 473 games
Compare with Young28.1
No. 904 all-time
Hal Trosky
first base, 1933–1946
9 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1933–1941, 1,124 games
Compare with Young27.9
No. 911 all-time
Greg Swindell
starting pitcher, 1986–2002
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1986–1996, 166 games
Compare with Young27.7
No. 917 all-time
Travis Fryman
third base, 1990–2002
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1998–2002, 602 games
Compare with Young27.6
No. 924 all-time
Bill Bradley
third base, 1899–1915
10 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1901–1910, 1,231 games
Compare with Young27.1
No. 953 all-time
Ray Boone
third base, 1948–1960
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1948–1953, 489 games
Compare with Young26.9
No. 965 all-time
Michael Brantley
left field, 2009–2023
10 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2009–2018, 1,051 games
Compare with Young26.7
No. 977 all-time
Red Donahue
starting pitcher, 1893–1906
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1903–1905, 71 games
Compare with Young26.5
No. 987 all-time
Al Smith
right field, 1946–1964
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1953–1964, 669 games
Compare with Young26.5
No. 994 all-time
Sherry Smith
starting pitcher, 1911–1927
6 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1922–1927, 141 games
Compare with Young26.3
No. 1,005 all-time
Mike Hargrove
first base, 1974–1985
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1979–1985, 888 games
Compare with Young26.1
No. 1,019 all-time
John Romano
catcher, 1958–1967
5 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1960–1964, 581 games
Compare with Young25.9
No. 1,030 all-time
John Denny
starting pitcher, 1974–1986
3 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1980–1982, 56 games
Compare with Young25.8
No. 1,032 all-time
Ray Chapman
shortstop, 1912–1920
9 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1912–1920, 1,051 games
Compare with Young25.7
No. 1,035 all-time
Charlie Hickman
first base, 1897–1908
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1902–1908, 385 games
Compare with Young25.7
No. 1,040 all-time
Monte Pearson
starting pitcher, 1932–1941
4 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1932–1935, 96 games
Compare with Young25.7
No. 1,040 all-time
Omar Vizquel
shortstop, 1989–2012
11 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1994–2004, 1,478 games
Compare with Young25.5
No. 1,050 all-time
Grady Sizemore
center field, 2004–2015
8 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 2004–2011, 892 games
Compare with Young25.2
No. 1,074 all-time
Mudcat Grant
starting pitcher, 1958–1971
7 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1958–1964, 294 games
Compare with Young24.4
No. 1,140 all-time
Charles Nagy
starting pitcher, 1990–2003
13 seasons on the Cleveland Guardians franchise, 1990–2002, 315 games
Compare with Young24.3
No. 1,151 all-time